The
Role of Zinc in the Treatment
of Tinnitus
- A Review -
by
Barry Keate
A
very positive and exciting new study was recently
published on the role of zinc in the treatment of
tinnitus. Published in the journal Otology
and Neurotology in January of 2003, the
study conducted a randomized, placebo-controlled
clinical trial at the Department of Ear, Nose and
Throat, Head and Neck Surgery at Ankara Hospital
in Ankara, Turkey.
The
complete transcript of the study can be viewed in
our Tinnitus Information Center on our website at
Info
Center/zinc study
The researchers tested 41 tinnitus patients between
April 2000 and May 2001. The patients ranged in
age from 21 to 74 years old. They all underwent
an otologic and audiologic examination to determine
that they had no pathological conditions that may
have been responsible for their tinnitus.
The
Method
Tinnitus match tests were performed and loudness
was determined both before and after treatment.
The patients were also asked to determine subjective
tinnitus loudness before and after treatment by
answering a series of 7 questions with a total possible
score of 0 (least intense) to 7 (most intense).
It was determined beforehand that a decrease in
tinnitus loudness of 10 dB would be considered as
clinically favorable progress and a decrease of
more than 1 point in subjective tinnitus scoring
would be accepted as valid.
The patients were then divided into two groups,
one to be treated with 50 mg zinc per day for 2
months and the other with placebo. There were 28
patients in the zinc group and 13 patients in the
placebo group. Blood zinc levels were measured in
all patients.
Findings
Blood zinc levels increased by an average of 20%
in the zinc group with some patients having as much
as a 38% increase. The placebo group had no increase
in zinc levels.
In
the zinc group, a decrease of 10 dB was considered
clinical improvement. In 13 patients (46.4%) loudness
decreased by more than this amount so the patients
were considered clinically improved. No one in the
placebo group improved.
Exciting
Results
Much more significant improvement was seen in subjective
symptoms. Of 28 patients given zinc, 23 of them
(82%) noted improvement in symptoms. Of 13 patients
given placebo, only 4 (22%) reported improvement.
The average tinnitus intensity of the zinc group
decreased from 5.25 (on a scale of 0 to 7) to 2.82.
This represents an average reduction of 46% in subjective
tinnitus intensity.
In
the zinc group, 10 patients out of 28 had low blood
zinc levels. Of these, the average tinnitus intensity
decreased from 5.3 to 2.4, which represents a 55%
reduction in symptoms. However, it is important
to note that tinnitus symptoms significantly decreased
even in those patients who did not have low zinc
levels.
Conclusions
The authors conclude that regardless of blood zinc
level being normal or low, the administration of
zinc improved not only blood zinc level but also
clinical disease. They think that improvement of
tinnitus and even of hearing may increase significantly
if zinc is given for 6 months or more.
The
authors believe the mechanism for this was the reduction
of what they term Reactive Oxygen Species (ROS).
Most of us are more familiar with the term free
radical. In other words, zinc acts as a powerful
antioxidant in the inner ear. They say that further
study is needed to determine the exact mechanism
by which zinc accomplishes this function.
This
study furthers our belief that zinc is a very necessary
component of hearing health. We wrote an article
last year on "Zinc, Tinnitus and Immune System Health",
which can be viewed at Info
Center - Zinc.
Getting
More Zinc in Your Diet (and
less tinnitus in your head)
Arches Tinnitus Relief Formula® gives you 20
mg of amino-acid chelated zinc on a daily basis.
We believe adding an additional 30 mg of zinc to
your daily diet may help to further enhance the
reduction of tinnitus symptoms. Many people already
get between 5 to 20 mg from a daily multivitamin.
Check the label to be certain that it is chelated
zinc. Avoid zinc oxide which is very difficult to
absorb.
Zinc is also found in many foods, especially in
meats, cheese and oysters. It is also in beans,
peanuts, broccoli and other green vegetables. Keep
your total zinc supplementation at/or below 50 mg.
If you plan on taking a higher dosage you should
be sure to add a few milligrams of extra copper
and manganese as well.